What’s to Like About Born Agains
I’m not saying conservative evangelicals don’t present a political problem for “my kind” and our allies—they do. And I’m not saying they’re not seriously misguided to ignorant in some matters, for that’s definitely the case. They’re also generally (not always) patriarchal, oblivious to the actual content of other faiths, problematically missionary, and blithely judgmental. And thanks to their limited theology, there are an awful lot of gay and lesbian folks trapped inside those cultures with very hurt hearts, leading double lives. I’m not dismissing their faults. But my recent four-day research stint, immersed in their world at a national “new church” conference, reminded me of the things I like about Born-Again Christians and why I enjoy burying myself from time to time in the ethnographic wonderland that is their world.
First, they are—by far—not all white. In fact, most African Americans are evangelical; a fact our larger culture tries to block out because we don’t know how to square it with our image of [bad, fascist, Evil] religious right. They’re also all stripes of Latino, African immigrant, Hmong, Chinese, Korean, and on and on. But that’s the subject of, oh, a whole book I’m writing, so I’ll set that bit of complexity aside for now.
They’re also really, really nice. Not in the flaky, vacuous way like, I don’t know, Delta Gamma girls (uh oh; yeah, I’m stereotyping). But nice in the way that people who are very concerned about your soul in eternity can be nice. Warm nice—as in wanting to know who you are, how you got here, where you came from, what you care about, and, yeah, how they can find a way to connect about Jesus and/or “share the gospel” with you. Every single time I have done research in an evangelical context I have felt entirely well hosted, warmly attended to, by these folks, even though I was from the get-go a suspicious other who any of them would have valid reason to suspect did not necessarily sympathize with their worldview. Still, they let me into their world and included me warmly, never pushing me to do anything, never getting in my face, never crossing a boundary once I’d set it, always giving me the benefit of the doubt. I’m honestly not sure my crowd would do the same for an evangelical researcher in our midst.
Now, I know this will set some of you to bristling, but Born Agains are really into love, into active loving, into creating a culture of active loving. I mean, there’s a part of it that’s not unlike what I imagine hippie culture was like in the sixties—without the large quantities of hallucinogens, of course, or the sexual freedom. (Although the Holy Spirit has some serious hallucinogenic properties, from what I’ve seen.) Sure, it’s hard to feel loved by them when some evangelicals are behind blocking our right to marry or control our bodies or whatever else. I don’t feel particularly loved by the phrase “love the sinner, hate the sin”—but, then again, I don’t feel particularly loved by the whole concept of sin. Hell, I don’t feel particularly loved by the phrase “civil unions.”
I do, though, feel a lot of active love when I walk into a room of evangelicals. I feel them trying so hard to love the other people in that room; to really love their kids in open, expressive, soft ways; to love their husbands and wives when it’s really hard; and to love each other even when serious conflict is bubbling up between them. To love me, the weirdo with the short hair and the tape recorder. And I’m flat impressed by this subgroup of evangelicals willing to love each other when they make all kinds of blunders trying to create multiracial, multiethnic churches. I have never seen that kind of love in cross-racial conversations on the left; anger and resentment are always the more tangible emotions. I can’t fault them for not working hard at it. Sure, this is also partly about loving “their own,” but most of them try harder to love those not part of their faith group than others I’ve met.
And oh how they are in love with their god, how they reach out to connect in meaningful ways with that god, to hear his voice in their hearts, to be guided by him, to be close. It’s intense and romantic, like the deepest teen crush you ever had, where you just lie in bed gazing at the ceiling, crazy out of your mind with want for your savior to come wrap you in infinitely loving arms and bring you home. Their spirituality is so tangible, so real, so untheoretical for them—even the intellectual ones who know their theology and Biblical exegesis inside out. Honestly, there’s something inspiring for me in that.
I also like that Born Again men are given a lot more room to be emotionally expressive, alone and in public, in this subculture. Watching those guys hold each other’s hands, embrace their “brothers and sisters in Christ,” toss their heads back and sing praise songs is a sight to see. There’s no shame for these guys in shedding tears. And sometimes when they “testify” about “what the Lord is doing” in their lives, their voices just drip with giddy enthusiasm, the likes of which guys in the outside world only get to express around other guys when inebriated. Yes, I have my own problems with Promise Keepers, but masculine emotional expression is not one of them.
Bottom line: Even though I’m pretty sure I wouldn’t want to be stuck on a deserted island with Born Agains, there are worse crowds I can think of (like Human Filler).
Miscellaneous likieness:
• I liked that I saw a young hippie evangelical sporting a black Che Guevara t-shirt.
• The African American pastor from Brooklyn who told me he was a “radical inclusionist”—which meant fighting for GLBT rights.
• The surprising sex appeal of the really gifted pastors.
• Hot, edgy evangelical babes (men) in low slung blue jeans (admittedly a minority to the sea of middle aged khaki wearers).
• Evangelical environmentalists.
• No Born Again at this conference of 5,000 ever made me feel like I should’ve worn a wig over my silver crew cut.
• The prayer spoken in Spanish, Portuguese, and Chinese at the closing of the multiethnic church building track.


Is it a crime to feel good?


